Most Outrageous - Introduction by Bob Levin
Most Outrageous: The Trials and Trespasses of Dwaine Tinsley and Chester the Molester
Most Outrageous: The Trials and Trespasses of Dwaine Tinsley and Chester the Molester
Price: $19.99

I had no idea what to do next.

For fifteen years, while practicing law in Berkeley, I had been writing about cartoonists for The Comics Journal. It had become apparent early on that the more off-beat the cartoonist was in his life or art, the more I would be drawn to him. Once my bias had become clear, someone at the Journal would have another cartoonist for me: a schizophrenic and an alcoholic and a speed freak and a suicide and a misanthrope and one fellow whose career off-tracked when he became a woman. Their work was often grotesquely violent, often bizarrely sexual. If there was an envelope to push, it was shoved with both hands. If there was a toe to step on, it was stomped with both boots. (Often these hands were bloody and these boots hobnailed.) I championed such work. I cheered such excesses. My point — laced with my own inappropriate humor and over-the-top effronteries — became that it was not the peculiarity of the personality that mattered but the value of the art and that this value heightened when the vision that produced it was extreme.

The attraction to me of espousing this belief, I suspected, lay in the stature I derived, at least in my own eyes, from connecting to the outlaw. I lived a life of modesty. The same wife for thirty-five years, the same house for thirty, the same car for twenty-five, the same office for twenty. I did not drink. I took a hit from the passing joint, maybe, once a year. Double espressos, I liked to say, were my last remaining vice. I required something more to set me apart from a culture that seemed as lethally seductive as flypaper, from a society that blithely returned to office those who seemed determined to bomb and pollute their way across the twenty-first century. I admired the way these voices said, “We are not you. You are not us.”

“You have never seen anything like it,” I had said to Robert the K, a glass artist and critic whose idea of a good time was attending four operas and three museums during a week in New York City. We were on our weekly walk, coming down a steep hill under grey skies in Tilden Park. Overhead, a solitary turkey buzzard hovered on the breeze. The “it” to which I referred was the scene the previous Sunday in Deadwood in which Al Swearengen, the saloon-and-brothel owner, bloody from his beating by the marshal, wracked with the pain of his inflamed prostate, declaims his acerbic view of the world while being fellated by a whore.

“Is that a true ground for artistic measure?” Robert said.

“Absolutely,” I said. “That’s the job of art. Show things that have never been seen. Say things that have never been heard. Explode people’s heads.”

“Do you ever feel a disconnect,” he said, “between yourself and these people and activities you write about? You are such a gentleman in other areas. It’s a question I often ask myself.”

It was a question I did not. But in early 2005, following the completion of a piece on Vaughn Bodé, I was stuck. Bod&eacute, a successful and influential cartoonist of the early 1970s, had been a bisexual, sadomasochistic transvestite who believed he was the Messiah, and had died of autoerotic strangulation. It had been a wonderful and thrilling article to write. But it wasn’t like I could now write about a cartoonist who was only a bisexual sadomasochist. My job — my aesthetic position — required the continual breaking of new ground.

Then, Eric Reynolds, publicity director for Fantagraphics, the company that publishes the Journal, e-mailed me: “I think I’ve found your next subject, Bob.” Attached was a two-year-old Internet posting commemorating the third anniversary of the death of Dwaine Tinsley, a cartoonist for Hustler magazine, whose major creation had been “Chester the Molester,” a monthly jest steeped in pedophilia, which had been nipped in mid-flowering when the cartoonist had been accused by his oldest daughter of several years of sexual abuse.

“Whoa!” I thought. “Are you sure you want to go there?” I could see the angry villagers, led by Andrew Vachss and Bill O’Reilly, marching on my castle, brandishing their torches and pitchforks.

Then I thought, “If you believe what you have been writing, you have to write this story. This is absolutely your next step. This is what you have been put on earth to do.”

A few weeks later, Gary Groth, the Journal’s editor-in-chief, called. “What are you working on?” he said.

I told him I had been thinking about Tinsley.

“I met his widow at a convention recently. She wanted me to do a collection of his cartoons. Really vile stuff. Want her number?”

I carried it around in my wallet for a few weeks. Once I checked the area code and saw it was Louisiana. “Great,” I thought. “The cost of interviewing her will be more than the Journal will pay. Besides, she probably won’t want to revisit the subject.”

Then, late one afternoon, I called.

Three weeks after that, my wife Adele and I arrived in New Orleans. Our first night, we ate at a restaurant where several adjoining tables had been covered with sheets of newspaper. When the last of about two dozen young men had been seated — in town, it turned out, for a bachelor party — for a bachelor party for a wedding to be held in Minneapolis — the waiters dumped bins of crayfish on the table. Then they dumped shrimp on the crayfish. Then they dumped crab on the shrimp. Being from the Bay Area, the way of life in other cities does not often impress us. But New Orleans kicked our ass. There was the cultural mix: French and Spanish; Caribbean and African. There was the music roaring from the bars — bars already open at 7:00 A.M., when we left our hotel in pursuit of egg-white omelets. There were the cemeteries roosting their dead above ground, more firmly planting them in sight and mind than did their more customary billeting. There was the Mississippi — Huck Finn’s Mississippi — the Mississippi that brought Chicago jazz — that utterly myth-resonant Mississippi, wide and dark, rushing past and vanishing into the gulf. Turn the corner and there was a bluegrass band or an illusionist or a hip-hop acrobatic troupe or a man or a woman, motionless, mute, made up to replicate a Greek god or plantation lady, to be observed or posed beside for a (hoped-for) donation. Each act was so skilled you might have been strolling through a fresh air Talk of the Town. Each was so startling — if a shade shabby, if the illusionist’s cuffs were somewhat frayed, if the silver paint on Hermes did not quite erase the desperation that froze him on his corner — that they seemed a civic planner’s slap into satori, designed to rouse one from fixation on the common into the richness and unpredictability of life. (“And in Berkeley,” Adele said, “they expect a quarter if they say, ‘Nice hat.’”) One night, in an occult shop off Rue Chartres, I purchased an African clawed frog — gigantic, hideous — pickled in formaldehyde. “Not to be taken internally,” the pierced-and-tattooed salesman said. “May cause hallucinations, convulsions and death.”

Ellen Tinsley lived with Mike Campbell and three dogs in Jefferson Parish, twenty minutes outside the French Quarter. The living room, with its stacks of CDs — Robert Johnson and Emmylou Harris and John Prine — and its bookshelves filled with the accumulations of decades — Dorothy Parker and W.H. Auden and a warts-and-boils biography of J. Edgar Hoover — would not have looked out of place on our block.

Mike, who is one size short of leading sweeps for the Dallas Cowboys, had a shaved head and Fu Manchu mustache. A former inspector for the Texas Food and Drug Administration, he had decided in his mid-forties to become a Delta blues musician. Now he played in front of the courthouse on Royal Street. When tourists give Mojo, one of the dogs, a dollar, he put it in Mike’s hat. Ellen, a handsome, red-haired woman from the Smokey Mountain region of North Carolina, wore a washed-out tank top, black jeans and sandals. She had come out of the University of Connecticut in the late 1960s to work with multiply handicapped children in the Detroit ghetto. Her father, a Lt. Commander in the Navy, was descended from Harry Morgan, the pirate, and Charles Kingsley, co-founder of the Christian Socialist movement. Her mother’s family had followed The Mayflower into port; and, later, the process of “civilizing” the natives had brought some Cherokee genes into her mix. She was a Daughter of the Republic, a Daughter of the Confederacy, and a former Miss Country Club, who describes herself, with a wicked smile, as someone who could be “a perfect lady in public, but, then, close the door…”

Ellen was neither the mother of the daughter who had brought the charges against Dwaine, nor the woman to whom he had been married when the offenses were said to have occurred. But she had been married to him the last five years of his life; and she fervently believed him the innocent victim of a vengeful, drug-addled young woman, a politically ambitious district attorney, and the lynch-mob mentality of an ultra-conservative community. She had attempted, unsuccessfully, to interest other writers in Dwaine’s story and, when that failed, to write it herself. Now a mammogram had revealed a lump upon which a biopsy had been inconclusive. “You have made my Monday,” she had said when I called.

Ellen had sent me twenty-five pages she had written, so I knew she considered Dwaine to have been a wonderful husband, a fine father to his two other daughters, and a masterful satiric artist, who had lifted himself, through extraordinary effort, from dire poverty to a professional peak. He was also “an enormously complex man,” “a non-stop talker, [who] in a five minute conversation could tell you a truly awful joke, discuss Monet’s use of light, dispense ‘Uncle Dwaine’ advice, and give you the latest in political intrigue,” someone who “mixed a massive vocabulary with a gutter mouth,” who “read everything from cereal boxes to Sartre,” who “laughed as easily as he cried,” who was “quick to anger and to admit mistakes,” who had friends “from every ethnic background, all different colors, sexual orientations, economic groups, and social classes,” who was “as comfortable with auto mechanics as he was with movie stars.” Now she asked why I was interested in him.

I told her about cartoonists with extreme visions and extreme lives.

She and Mike waited for something more.

“I don’t have an agenda,” I said. “This will be a lot easier to write if I believe he didn’t do it; but, right now, I don’t know. All I can promise you is an open mind.”

Ellen answered my questions for two hours. Then she asked us to dinner. Mike had smoked a turkey. Ellen had made red beans and rice. After dinner, she invited us into the garage. When we left, we took away two storage boxes filled with Dwaine’s case documents and personal papers. Back in our motel, two items caught my eye. One was a picture of Dwaine and his daughter. She is in her teens, when the abuse was supposedly raging. She is seated behind him on a rock. Both her arms are thrown around him and her chin rests on his right shoulder. She has a broad smile and he a light one. She appears totally relaxed, totally at ease, totally trusting. The other was a shot of Dwaine and Ellen. He is nuzzling her neck from behind.Both his arms embrace her and she holds one of his hands. Deep affection fills both their eyes. “This is a man who desires women,” Adele said, “not little girls.”

I was happy to hear that. However it turned out though — whatever madness or perversion explained the behavior at the story’s core — it could not be treated with my accustomed style. Whether I was to meet a bestial father or deranged daughter — whether I was to find doubloons in the storage boxes or Pandora’s demons — I saw pain and tragedy dripping from this tale like Spanish moss. I heard shrieks and moans and skeletons rattling and garments rending. I saw no place for humor — no room to layer in effrontery. I felt terribly excited. I felt the thrill of entering the realm of the taboo. I felt like a character in a Hitchcock movie, drawn into a plot over which he has no control, headed for a destination he cannot foretell.

Across the room, the frog grinned through its formaldehyde cloud.

Featured books by Bob Levin (click covers for complete product details)

Most Outrageous: The Trials and Trespasses of Dwaine Tinsley and Chester the Molester
Most Outrageous: The Trials and Trespasses of Dwaine Tinsley and Chester the Molester
Price: $19.99

All books by Bob Levin